"Mine, I fear, is not a well-regulated mind: it has an occasional tenderness for old abuses; it lingers with a certain fondness over the days of nasal clerks and top-booted parsons and has a sigh for the departed shades of vulgar errors."
Scenes of Clerical Life represents Eliot's first published fiction; its three stories came out in Blackwood's Magazine in 1857; they were collected into the book the following year. She was already reasonably well-known under her real name as an essayist and translator from the German, but the first story was published anonymously before she coined the pseudonym for subsequent publications.
The stories take place in the past, twenty, thirty, sixty years ago. They are either the times of George Eliot's childhood or represent stories of the further past that might have been told in George Eliot's childhood. They're narrated in a first-person voice, but the narrator is not a character in any of the stories, and in at least one is explicitly recalling childhood. They all take place in the same fictional space (closely based on Nuneaton, Wikipedia tells me, where George Eliot grew up) and characters overlap between the stories.
"The Sad Fortunes of the Rev. Amos Barton" is the first of the three stories. Amos Barton is the Vicar of Shepparton, happily married with six beloved children. He's a reasonably good vicar, though no saint. To be sure he holds multiple livings, but has to pay curates to do the work for all except the one, and he doesn't make enough to live on. He loves his wife, but doesn't think much about her. The Bartons get involved in charity toward the fairly dubious Countess Czernacki, and their finances go from bad to worse. George Eliot's ironic tolerance is in fine form and it's the funniest of the stories until, well, it isn't.
The second story is "Mr. Gilfil's Love Story". Mr. Gilfil is just before Amos Barton's time, and the town thinks of him as old and sedate, just a little bit boring, and fortunately given to preaching short sermons. But, as it turns out, that's not the full story.
"Janet's Repentance" is the last and longest of the three stories. The Rev. Tryan comes to town, working among the poor weavers; he wants to start an evening lecture at the church. But the respectable elements of the town accuse Tryan of Methodism or worse; his case is not helped by the support of Mr. Jerome, the town's one well-to-do Dissenter. The lawyer Dempster organizes the opposition to Tryan, with the aid of his wife Janet.
The town admires Dempster as a clever and not overly scrupulous lawyer, but he drinks too much. Janet joins her husband in his campaign to smear Tryan, not so much out of conviction, but as a way to reignite the love between them that had soured since they first married.
I thought this one took a little long to get going and in the beginning there was too much simple picturing of the people of the town, so I'd say it's the weakest; but it does get going and makes a pretty good story as well.
So, are these Middlemarch? Well, no. But even second-rate George Eliot is still awfully good, and it's nice, in a way, to see that she didn't first appear full-grown in armor like Athena from the head of Zeus, but had to work to get better. And did. Gives some hope for the rest of us...
A book from my classics club list
and one for the Karen's Back to the Classics Challenge.
It also means I've only got one volume left to read in that collected Eliot shown above, the volume with the poems, a play (!) and The Impressions of Theophrastus Such, Eliot's last work.
The collected George Eliot posts on the blog.
i read this about ten years ago i think it was and i didn't make as nearly as much out of it as you did... very interesting post...ReplyDelete
Thanks! I definitely enjoyed them, especially the first two, and it's interesting to see them in the full context.Delete
:D You're right; even second-rate Eliot novels are still pretty good.ReplyDelete
You've read almost all of Eliot's works?! That's awesome! I've wanted to read Scenes of a Clerical Life, mostly because it has such a lovely title. Thankfully I don't expect it to be as good as Middlemarch so I won't be disappointed.ReplyDelete
"Gives some hope for the rest of us .." You said it! We must always strive to be better.
Not part of that set, but I've also got her translation of Ludwig Feuerbach's The Essence of Christianity. I may have gotten a little compulsive there...Delete
The Sad Fortunes of the Rev. Amos Barton" sounds like a plot Trollope might use.ReplyDelete
I've only read Middlemarch by Elliot but have been circling The Mill on the Floss for a while. Maybe if Karen continues with Back to the Classics in 2020 I will try it then. :D
There definitely are some other great ones. If you still need this year's novella ;-) then Silas Marner probably is short enough, and I'd say it was #2 of Eliot, though Mill on the Floss is awfully good, too.Delete
I love your set! I've only got a nice edition of Middlemarch, but I'm fond of it. The others are old Penguins. She's one of my favourite classic writers and I was just thinking, with the 200 year celebrations coming up at the end of this year (I think?) that I should think of some rereading. Clerical isn't one that I've got or read, though. I think someone discouraged me from it. But it sounds quite charming. Maybe a little like Sarah Orne Jewitt's Country of the Pointed Firs? Also a little rambly at times, but very picturesque and charming all the same.ReplyDelete
I haven't read Country of the Pointed Firs so I can't compare (one to look forward to!) but I did quite like this. Really Romola is the only one I didn't much like, though, so maybe I'm not the least biased source. ;-)Delete
It is a cute set, though I don't imagine it was expensive when it came out & the type isn't amazing. And it was broken when I got it--my Felix Holt is in an old Penguin...