Monday, November 5, 2018

Nonfiction November: Fiction and Nonfiction Pairing


It's the second week of Nonfiction November and Sarah (thanks for co-hosting!) of Sarah's Bookshelves challenges us to match up nonfiction reading with fiction reading. I've got two that have been in my mind for a while, one for a very long time.

Steinbeck On How To Write A Novel (with Novel)

Humpty, meet John; John, meet Humpty

This one occurred to me when I found a copy of John Steinbeck's Journal of A Novel at a charity sale last fall. Steinbeck decided to write regular letters to his editor, Pat Covici, while he was working on East of Eden about his process. Journal of a Novel collects those letters.

I read East of Eden years ago, though I've seen the movie more recently; it's one of the great Steinbeck novels, even if I find Cathy Ames just a wee bit too monstrous. ("Bad divorce, John?" "Humpty, let me tell you! Grumble, grumble...") But the idea is to read them both together.

And Now I'm Ready At Last...

Humpty had a great Fall (or at least Nonfiction November)
Years ago I started reading Edmund Wilson's Axel's Castle (literary criticism about Joyce, Proust, Eliot, Yeats, Valery, and Gertrude Stein published in 1931) and I thought (at the time) this is hopeless! I haven't read any of these books. Generally I like Wilson's nonfiction, especially To The Finland Station.

Well, I had probably read Eliot's Old Possum's Book of Practical Cats by then, which is hiding in there between Yeats and Proust. But still.

Now, it's years later, and while I'm sure there are still books discussed in Axel's Castle I haven't read, I'm kind of hoping I'm close enough to make sense of the book. In any case I put it on my Classics Club list.

Finnegans Wake (in the picture) is still Unnamed Work In Progress at the time of Axel's Castle. Wilson managed to score a couple of passages and quoted them at the end of his book, but fortunately won't be discussing that particular still-for-me unreadable volume of Joyce.

Missing from the picture is Gertrude Stein. I don't know where she's hiding...shy, I guess...

Looking forward to other great pairings. Happy Nonfiction November!

12 comments:

  1. Finally, someone else who found Cathy Ames a little over the top! I finished East of Eden but I must say that I didn't really enjoy it. Journal of a Novel might be interesting though.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I did like East of Eden but Cathy Ames nearly ruined it for me. One of things I'm curious about is what Steinbeck says about her character in the letters.

      Delete
  2. I'm planning to reread East of Eden one day - will source a copy of the letters before I do though - thanks :-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Once I stumbled on a copy of Journal of a Novel, East of Eden moved up my reread list, but it hasn't quite happened yet...

      Delete
  3. That's an interesting Steinbeck pairing. I have not read East of Eden, though it's one I should really read. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I do think East of Eden one of the better Steinbecks, even if he's not quite fair to Cathy Ames.

      Delete
  4. I actually did read Journal of a Novel right after East of Eden not long ago. It was fascinating to have a look into Steinbeck's creative process!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cool! Glad for the affirmation that it is a good idea!

      Delete
  5. neat presentation. East of Eden is my favorite by Steinbeck. Here's my post: https://wordsandpeace.com/2018/11/07/nonfiction-november-2018-book-pairings/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I probably prefer Of Mice and Men, but East of Eden is one of the great ones!

      Delete